Store Brand Snacks vs. Name Brand: Taste Test and Price Showdown

RefillWatch is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. We maintain editorial independence; our reviews and recommendations are based on thorough research and objective analysis of value.

Store Brand Snacks vs. Name Brand: Taste Test and Price Showdown

Are you throwing away money on name-brand snacks? The grocery store shelves are packed with affordable store-brand alternatives, but are they any good? We put popular store brand snacks head-to-head against their well-known counterparts in a blind taste test and price comparison to see if you can save money without sacrificing flavor. Prepare to have your snack assumptions challenged!

Methodology: Blind Taste Test and Current Prices

We focused on five common snack categories: potato chips, cheese crackers, sandwich cookies, cola, and trail mix. For each category, we purchased both a leading name-brand option and the corresponding store-brand version from a major national grocery chain.

Blind Taste Test: Family members participated in a blind taste test. Snacks were presented in unmarked bowls, and testers rated each snack on a scale of 1 to 5 for overall taste and texture. We recorded the results and calculated average scores for each snack.

Price Comparison: We recorded the price per ounce (or per serving where applicable) for both the name-brand and store-brand snacks. This allowed us to directly compare the cost savings offered by the store-brand options. Prices were gathered during the same shopping trip to ensure accuracy.

Potato Chips: Can You Taste the Difference?

Potato chips are a staple snack, but the price of name-brand chips can add up quickly. We compared Lay’s Classic Potato Chips to the store-brand version.

Taste Test Results: Potato Chips

The taste test revealed a surprising outcome. While Lay’s received an average score of 4.2 out of 5, the store-brand chips scored a respectable 3.9. Most tasters noted a slightly different texture, with the store-brand chips being slightly thicker. However, the overall flavor profile was very similar.

Price Comparison: Potato Chips

• Lay’s Classic Potato Chips (13 oz bag): $4.99 ($0.38/oz)
• Store-Brand Potato Chips (13 oz bag): $2.99 ($0.23/oz)

Savings: Choosing the store-brand chips saved you $2.00 per bag, a 30% price reduction.

Verdict: Potato Chips

For potato chips, the store-brand option offers significant savings with only a minor difference in taste. If you’re looking to cut costs without sacrificing much in terms of flavor, the store-brand chips are an excellent choice.

Cheese Crackers: Are Goldfish Still the Gold Standard?

Cheese crackers are another popular snack, especially for kids. We compared Pepperidge Farm Goldfish to the store-brand cheese crackers.

Taste Test Results: Cheese Crackers

The Goldfish crackers emerged as the clear winner in the taste test, receiving an average score of 4.5 out of 5. Tasters praised their distinct cheesy flavor and satisfying crunch. The store-brand cheese crackers scored a 3.2, with tasters noting a blander flavor and slightly softer texture.

Price Comparison: Cheese Crackers

• Pepperidge Farm Goldfish (6.6 oz bag): $3.49 ($0.53/oz)
• Store-Brand Cheese Crackers (6.6 oz bag): $2.49 ($0.38/oz)

Savings: Switching to the store-brand cheese crackers saves $1.00 per bag, or almost 30%.

Verdict: Cheese Crackers

While the store-brand cheese crackers are cheaper, the taste test revealed a significant difference in flavor and texture. If you or your family are die-hard Goldfish fans, the extra cost might be worth it. However, if you’re willing to compromise on taste, the store-brand offers substantial savings.

Sandwich Cookies: Oreo vs. the Imposter

Sandwich cookies are a classic treat, and Oreo is the king of the category. We compared Oreo cookies to the store-brand sandwich cookies.

Taste Test Results: Sandwich Cookies

The taste test results were overwhelmingly in favor of Oreo. The name-brand cookies received an average score of 4.8 out of 5, with tasters praising their creamy filling and distinct chocolate flavor. The store-brand cookies scored a 2.8, with tasters describing the filling as grainy and the chocolate flavor as weak.

Price Comparison: Sandwich Cookies

• Oreo Cookies (14.3 oz package): $4.29 ($0.30/oz)
• Store-Brand Sandwich Cookies (14.3 oz package): $2.99 ($0.21/oz)

Savings: Opting for the store-brand sandwich cookies saves $1.30 per package, a roughly 30% savings.

Verdict: Sandwich Cookies

In this case, the taste difference was significant enough to warrant the higher price of Oreos for many consumers. While the store-brand cookies are cheaper, the taste and texture differences were noticeable and not particularly appealing to our testers.

Cola: Can a Generic Cola Satisfy Your Thirst?

Cola is a ubiquitous beverage, and the market is dominated by Coca-Cola and Pepsi. We compared Coca-Cola to the store-brand cola. When it comes to beverages, consider if bottled or canned options are creeping up in price. It may be time to invest in a reusable water bottleAmazon → and a water filter!

Taste Test Results: Cola

The taste test revealed a clear preference for Coca-Cola, which received an average score of 4.6 out of 5. Tasters described the flavor as crisp, refreshing, and well-balanced. The store-brand cola scored a 3.0, with tasters noting a slightly artificial taste and a less pronounced fizz.

Price Comparison: Cola

• Coca-Cola (12-pack of 12 oz cans): $6.99 ($0.05/oz)
• Store-Brand Cola (12-pack of 12 oz cans): $4.99 ($0.03/oz)

Savings: Choosing the store-brand cola saves $2.00 per 12-pack, a savings of around 28%.

Verdict: Cola

While the store-brand cola is cheaper, the taste difference was noticeable. If you’re particular about your cola, Coca-Cola is likely worth the extra cost. However, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly option and aren’t too picky about the flavor, the store-brand cola can be a reasonable substitute.

Trail Mix: A Healthy Snack Showdown?

Trail mix is often marketed as a healthy snack, but the price can be high. We compared a popular name-brand trail mix to the store-brand version.

Taste Test Results: Trail Mix

The taste test revealed a slight preference for the name-brand trail mix, which received an average score of 4.0 out of 5. Tasters liked the variety of ingredients and the balance of sweet and salty flavors. The store-brand trail mix scored a 3.7, with tasters noting a slightly lower quality of nuts and a less appealing mix of ingredients.

Price Comparison: Trail Mix

• Name-Brand Trail Mix (10 oz bag): $5.99 ($0.60/oz)
• Store-Brand Trail Mix (10 oz bag): $4.49 ($0.45/oz)

Savings: Switching to the store-brand trail mix saves $1.50 per bag, a savings of 25%.

Verdict: Trail Mix

The store-brand trail mix offers a reasonable compromise between price and quality. While the name-brand mix had a slightly better taste and texture, the store-brand option is significantly cheaper and still provides a satisfying snack.

The Bottom Line: Smart Snacking Strategies

Our taste test and price showdown demonstrate that store-brand snacks can offer significant savings compared to their name-brand counterparts. While some taste differences exist, they are often minimal, making store-brand snacks a smart choice for budget-conscious shoppers. However, it’s important to consider individual preferences. In categories like cheese crackers and sandwich cookies, the taste difference may be significant enough to warrant paying more for the name-brand option.

Here are some key takeaways:

• Read the labels: Compare ingredient lists and nutritional information to ensure the store-brand option meets your dietary needs.
• Start with small quantities: If you’re unsure about a store-brand snack, buy a small package to try before committing to a larger purchase.
• Don’t be afraid to experiment: Store-brand options vary in quality, so try different brands to find your favorites.
• Track prices: Keep an eye on prices to identify the best deals and avoid shrinkflation. RefillWatch is dedicated to helping you track these price changes, so you can make informed decisions about your purchases.

By following these tips, you can enjoy your favorite snacks without breaking the bank. Next time you’re at the grocery store, consider giving store-brand snacks a try – you might be surprised at how much you can save. Also, consider investing in home staples like quality 8.5 x 11 paperAmazon → when it’s on sale to avoid price creep.