How to choose printer ink

Printer ink. It’s one of those household consumables that seems to have a habit of disappearing faster than a free sample at Costco. And the replacement cost? Often feels like you’re buying a new printer every time. RefillWatch has been tracking ink prices for years, and the trends aren’t always pretty. This guide will help you navigate the murky waters of printer ink, ensuring you get the most out of every drop without overpaying.

RefillWatch is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. When you click on our links and make a purchase, we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. This helps support our independent review process.

Understanding Your Printer’s Ink Needs

Before you even think about buying ink, you need to understand what your printer actually uses. This isn’t as simple as just knowing the brand.

Cartridge Numbers: The Universal Identifier

Every printer cartridge has a specific number or code. This is your most critical piece of information. It’s usually printed prominently on the cartridge itself, and often on a sticker inside the printer’s cartridge bay. Don’t rely solely on your printer model number, as some models, even within the same series, can use different cartridges depending on region or specific features.

For example, an HP 67XL Black Ink Cartridge is designed for a range of HP DeskJet and Envy printers. Trying to force an HP 65XL into a printer designed for a 67XL will, at best, not work, and at worst, damage your printer. We’ve seen enough complaint volume on retailer Q&A sections from users who bought the wrong cartridge to know this is a common pitfall. Always double-check the cartridge number before purchasing.

Dye-Based vs. Pigment-Based Ink

This is where the science comes in, and it significantly impacts print quality and longevity.

• Dye-based inks are water-soluble and consist of colorants dissolved in a liquid. They produce vibrant colors, are excellent for glossy photo printing, and generally have a wider color gamut. However, they are more susceptible to fading over time, especially when exposed to UV light, and can be prone to smudging if they get wet. Most everyday home printers use dye-based inks, especially for color.
• Pigment-based inks use solid particles of color that are suspended in a liquid. These inks bind to the paper fibers, making them more resistant to water, smudging, and fading. They offer sharper text and are ideal for documents and archival prints. The trade-off is often a slightly less vibrant color output compared to dye-based inks, and they can be more expensive. Many professional photo printers and printers geared towards business documents use pigment-based inks, particularly for black.

Some printers, like certain Epson models, use a hybrid system, with pigment black for sharp text and dye-based colors for vibrant images. Knowing which type of ink your printer uses can guide your expectations for print quality and longevity, and help you understand why some cartridges cost more than others.

Standard vs. XL/High-Yield Cartridges

This is a key area where retailers often play games with unit pricing. Standard cartridges contain less ink, while XL or high-yield versions contain more. The “XL” or “high-yield” designation doesn’t mean the cartridge is physically larger; it simply means it’s filled to a higher capacity.

Our weekly tracking consistently shows that high-yield cartridges almost always offer a significantly better cost per page. For example, a standard black cartridge might print 120 pages, while its XL counterpart prints 400 pages for less than double the price. The unit cost difference can be as much as 30-50% in your favor. Unless you print exceptionally rarely (say, less than 10 pages a month) and are worried about ink drying out, always opt for the high-yield version. It’s a no-brainer for budget-minded households.

OEM vs. Compatible/Remanufactured Ink: The Great Debate

This is perhaps the most contentious area in the world of printer ink. Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) ink is made by the same company that made your printer (HP, Canon, Epson, Brother, etc.). Compatible or remanufactured cartridges are made by third-party companies.

The OEM Argument: Quality and Reliability

Printer manufacturers strongly advocate for their own OEM cartridges. Their arguments typically center on:

• Print Quality: OEM inks are formulated specifically for their print heads, promising optimal color accuracy, sharpness, and consistency.
• Printer Longevity: They claim third-party inks can clog print heads, lead to premature printer failure, or void warranties.
• Reliability: Fewer clogs, leaks, and compatibility issues.

From our tracking, OEM inks generally do deliver on consistency. We rarely see complaint volume spikes related to fundamental quality issues with fresh OEM cartridges. However, their primary downside is consistently higher unit cost. A single Canon PGI-280 XXL Black Ink Tank can cost as much as a budget printer itself.

The Compatible/Remanufactured Argument: Cost Savings

Third-party cartridges are designed to be a direct replacement for OEM cartridges, often at a fraction of the price.

• Compatible cartridges are newly manufactured by a third party, designed to meet or exceed OEM specifications.
• Remanufactured cartridges are recycled OEM cartridges that have been cleaned, refilled with third-party ink, and tested.

The appeal here is purely financial. You can often find compatible cartridges for 50-70% less than OEM. But there are risks:

• Variable Quality: This is the biggest wildcard. Some third-party manufacturers produce excellent ink that performs nearly identically to OEM. Others produce ink that clogs print heads, leaks, or delivers subpar print quality (streaky lines, inaccurate colors).
• Compatibility Issues: Printer manufacturers often update firmware to detect and reject non-OEM cartridges. This can lead to frustrating “non-genuine cartridge” error messages, rendering your purchase useless.
• Warranty Concerns: While it’s generally illegal for a printer warranty to be voided simply by using third-party ink (Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act in the US), manufacturers can deny warranty claims if they can prove the third-party ink directly caused the printer malfunction. This is a gray area and often difficult for consumers to fight.

Our recommendation on compatibles is cautious. For high-volume, non-critical printing (e.g., kids’ homework, rough drafts), they can be a significant money-saver. However, for important documents, professional presentations, or photo printing where color accuracy is paramount, sticking with OEM is safer. If you do go the compatible route, look for brands with strong, consistent reviews and a clear return policy. Check retailer Q&A sections for recent complaints about firmware updates rendering specific compatibles useless.

Ink Subscription Services: Convenience at a Cost?

Many printer manufacturers now offer ink subscription services (e.g., HP Instant Ink, Epson ReadyPrint, Canon PIXMA Print Plan). These services promise to deliver ink to your door before you run out, based on your estimated page usage.

How They Work

You typically subscribe to a plan based on the number of pages you expect to print per month (e.g., 50 pages, 100 pages, 300 pages). The printer communicates its ink levels and page count to the manufacturer, and new cartridges are automatically shipped when needed. Unused pages often roll over to the next month, up to a certain limit.

The RefillWatch Take: Proceed with Caution

On the surface, these sound convenient and potentially cost-effective, especially for those who print consistently. However, our tracking reveals several caveats:

• Unit Cost Can Be Higher: While the per-page cost can appear low, especially on lower-tier plans, it’s often based on the assumption that you’re printing full-color, high-coverage pages. If you print mostly text, the per-page cost can be significantly higher than buying high-yield OEM cartridges outright.
• “Page” Definition: A “page” is a page, regardless of how much ink is on it. A single line of text counts the same as a full-color photograph. This can inflate your perceived usage.
• Printer Lock-in: If you cancel the subscription, the special cartridges provided by the service often stop working, even if they’re still full. You’re then forced to buy new retail cartridges. This is a significant lock-in mechanism.
• Data Collection: Your printer is constantly communicating with the manufacturer. While primarily for ink levels, it’s worth considering the privacy implications.
• Subscription Creep: We’ve noted a trend of quiet price increases on these subscription plans over time. What starts as a great deal can slowly become less competitive. Our internal household log for one popular service showed a 15% price hike over two years for the same page tier.

Ink subscriptions can make sense for very specific users: those who print a consistent, high volume of mixed content (text and color photos) and prioritize convenience above all else. For most budget-conscious users, buying high-yield cartridges when on sale is usually the more economical choice. [INTERNAL:how-to-cancel-ink-subscription] has more details on avoiding these pitfalls.

Maximizing Your Ink Cartridge Life

Even with the right ink choice, how you use and maintain your printer can drastically impact how long your cartridges last.

Print Regularly, But Not Excessively

Printers are designed to be used. Infrequent printing can lead to ink drying out in the print heads, causing clogs and requiring head cleaning cycles (which use a surprising amount of ink). Aim to print something, even a test page, at least once a week.

However, don’t print things you don’t need. Every print job, no matter how small, uses ink. Think before you click “print.”

Utilize Print Settings

Your printer’s settings are your best friend for ink conservation.

• Draft Mode: For internal documents, rough drafts, or anything that doesn’t need pristine quality, use “Draft” or “Economy” mode. This uses less ink and often prints faster.
• Grayscale/Black & White: Unless color is essential, print in black and white. Color ink is often more expensive per milliliter.
• Print Preview: Always use print preview to catch errors or unnecessary pages before printing.
• Page Layout: If printing web pages, use a “print-friendly” option if available, or copy and paste relevant text into a word processor to avoid printing ads and navigation bars.

Proper Storage of Spare Cartridges

Ink cartridges have a shelf life. While not as perishable as milk, they can dry out or degrade if stored improperly.

• Keep them in their original, sealed packaging until ready to use. This protects them from air exposure and light.
• Store them in a cool, dark place, away from direct sunlight or extreme temperatures. A drawer or cupboard is ideal.
• Check the expiration date if one is provided. While ink might still work past this date, quality can diminish, and manufacturers might not honor warranties.

Don’t Panic at “Low Ink” Warnings

Printer manufacturers are notorious for issuing “low ink” warnings well before a cartridge is actually empty. These warnings are often based on algorithms, not actual ink levels. You can often get dozens, if not hundreds, more pages out of a cartridge after the first warning appears. Keep printing until you notice a visible degradation in print quality (fading, streaks, missing colors). At that point, it’s time to change.

When to Consider a New Printer

Sometimes, the best way to save money on ink is to re-evaluate your printer itself.

The “Ink Tank” Revolution

In recent years, several manufacturers have introduced “ink tank” printers (e.g., Epson EcoTank, Canon MegaTank, HP Smart Tank, Brother INKvestment Tank). Instead of small, expensive cartridges, these printers use large, refillable ink tanks. You buy bottles of ink, which are significantly cheaper per milliliter than cartridges, and manually top up the tanks.

Our unit pricing analysis shows these offer dramatically lower running costs over the long term. Initial printer cost is higher, but the ink savings can be substantial, especially for high-volume users. For example, a single bottle of Epson EcoTank 502 Black Ink can print thousands of pages, costing pennies per page. If you’re printing hundreds of pages a month, the payback period on the higher initial printer cost can be surprisingly short. [INTERNAL:best-ink-tank-printers] dives deeper into specific models.

Laser Printers for Text

If your printing is almost exclusively black-and-white text documents, a monochrome laser printer is often a far more economical choice than an inkjet. Toner cartridges (used in laser printers) have a much higher page yield and lower cost per page for text than inkjet cartridges. They also don’t dry out like liquid ink. A basic laser printer like the Brother HL-L2370DW can be a workhorse, and its toner cartridges last for thousands of pages.

Assess Your Usage Patterns

Take an honest look at how much