Aluminum Foil vs. Plastic Wrap: Which is Cheaper for Food Storage?

RefillWatch is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This helps us keep tracking those price hikes.

Aluminum Foil vs. Plastic Wrap: Which is Cheaper for Food Storage?

We’ve all been there: leftovers from dinner, a half-eaten avocado, or a sandwich for lunch. The question then becomes, “What’s the best way to keep it fresh?” The two most common answers are aluminum foil and plastic wrap. But beyond freshness, there’s another crucial factor: cost. With grocery prices constantly fluctuating, figuring out the most economical option is more important than ever.

This article dives into a head-to-head comparison of aluminum foil vs. plastic wrap cost, breaking down the numbers to reveal which offers the better value for your money. We’ll also explore alternative options to help you save even more and reduce waste.

Calculating the Cost Per Square Foot

The key to comparing aluminum foil and plastic wrap is understanding the cost per square foot. This allows for a fair comparison, regardless of roll size or brand. Here’s how to calculate it:

1. Determine the dimensions: Check the packaging for the length and width of the roll. Length is usually in feet, and width in inches.
2. Convert to consistent units: Convert the width from inches to feet by dividing by 12.
3. Calculate the total square footage: Multiply the length (in feet) by the width (in feet).
4. Find the price: Note the price you paid for the roll (or the current online price).
5. Divide the price by the total square footage: This gives you the cost per square foot.

Let’s look at a hypothetical example:

• Aluminum Foil: A roll is 50 feet long and 12 inches wide.

  • Width in feet: 12 inches / 12 inches/foot = 1 foot
  • Total square footage: 50 feet * 1 foot = 50 square feet
  • Price of roll: $4.00
  • Cost per square foot: $4.00 / 50 sq ft = $0.08 per square foot

• Plastic Wrap: A roll is 200 feet long and 12 inches wide.

  • Width in feet: 12 inches / 12 inches/foot = 1 foot
  • Total square footage: 200 feet * 1 foot = 200 square feet
  • Price of roll: $6.00
  • Cost per square foot: $6.00 / 200 sq ft = $0.03 per square foot

In this scenario, plastic wrap is significantly cheaper at $0.03 per square foot compared to aluminum foil at $0.08 per square foot. However, prices vary depending on brand, store, and promotions. Time to hit the aisles (or online storefronts) to do your own comparison!

Factors Affecting Price

Several factors can influence the price of both products:

• Brand: Name brands often come with a premium.
• Roll Size: Larger rolls typically offer a lower cost per square foot, but require a larger upfront investment.
• Features: Heavy-duty foil or plastic wrap with extra cling can be more expensive.
• Store: Prices can vary between different retailers, so compare prices at your local grocery store, warehouse club (like Costco or Sam’s Club), and online retailers.
• Promotions: Keep an eye out for sales and discounts. Buying in bulk or using coupons can lower your overall cost.

Real-World Price Check: Current Online Examples

To give you a clearer picture, let’s look at some current online prices (prices checked 10/26/2023):

• Reynolds Wrap Aluminum Foil (200 sq ft): Around $14.00, making it $0.07 per square foot.
• Kirkland Signature Foodservice Foil (500 sq ft): Around $28.00, making it $0.056 per square foot.
• Saran Premium Plastic Wrap (200 sq ft): Around $12.00, making it $0.06 per square foot.
• Glad Press’n Seal (140 sq ft): Around $9.00, making it $0.064 per square foot.

These examples show that aluminum foil can be cheaper, especially when buying in bulk. However, the price difference is often minimal, and plastic wrap can still be more economical depending on the brand and roll size.

Beyond Price: Considering Usage and Waste

Cost isn’t the only factor to consider. How you use aluminum foil and plastic wrap, and the environmental impact of each, also play a significant role.

Reusability and Durability

• Aluminum Foil: Can be reused, especially for covering dishes in the oven or grill. However, once crumpled or heavily soiled, it’s usually discarded.
• Plastic Wrap: Generally single-use. While some people try to reuse it, it loses its cling and is difficult to clean.

If you’re diligent about reusing aluminum foil, you can effectively lower its cost per use.

Specific Use Cases

• Aluminum Foil: Ideal for high-heat cooking, grilling, and lining baking sheets. It’s also great for wrapping leftovers that need to be reheated in the oven.
• Plastic Wrap: Best for covering bowls and plates in the refrigerator, wrapping sandwiches, and preventing cut fruits and vegetables from browning. It’s also useful for steaming vegetables in the microwave.

Consider what you’re storing or cooking. Using the most appropriate material can extend the life of your food and reduce waste.

Environmental Impact

• Aluminum Foil: Recyclable, but only if it’s clean. Food residue can contaminate recycling batches.
• Plastic Wrap: Rarely recyclable. Most types end up in landfills.

If environmental concerns are a priority, aluminum foil might be the better choice, provided you recycle it properly.

Smarter Swaps: Alternatives to Foil and Plastic Wrap

Ultimately, the most cost-effective and environmentally friendly approach is to minimize your use of both aluminum foil and plastic wrap. Here are some alternatives to consider:

Reusable Food Storage Containers

Investing in a set of reusable food storage containers, like glass or BPA-free plastic containers, can eliminate the need for both foil and plastic wrap. While the initial cost is higher, these containers can last for years, making them a worthwhile investment. Look for sets with airtight lids to keep food fresh longer.

Beeswax Wraps

Beeswax wraps are a natural and reusable alternative. Made from cotton fabric coated in beeswax, tree resin, and jojoba oil, these wraps are moldable and can be used to cover bowls, wrap sandwiches, and store cheese. They can be washed with cool water and gentle soap and reused for up to a year.

Silicone Food Covers

Silicone food covers are stretchy and can fit over a variety of containers. They’re reusable, dishwasher-safe, and heat-resistant, making them a versatile alternative to plastic wrap.

Fabric Bowl Covers

Elasticized fabric bowl covers are another reusable option. These covers slip over bowls and plates, keeping food fresh without the need for plastic wrap or foil. They’re washable and come in various sizes.

Refillable Wrap Dispensers for Plastic Wrap

While not an elimination of plastic wrap, switching to a refillable plastic wrap dispenserAmazon → can help. These dispensers often feature a slide cutter and can be refilled with economical bulk rolls of plastic wrap, reducing the amount of cardboard waste.

The Verdict: What’s the Cheapest Option?

The answer to “aluminum foil vs plastic wrap cost?” isn’t always straightforward. It depends on a variety of factors, including brand, roll size, store, and promotions. However, by calculating the cost per square foot and considering your usage habits, you can make an informed decision.

Generally:

• Plastic wrap can be cheaper per square foot. However, be sure to compare brands and roll sizes.
• Reusing aluminum foil can lower its cost per use.
• Reusable alternatives offer the best long-term value and reduce waste.

The best approach is to combine cost-effective strategies with environmentally conscious choices. Consider buying plastic wrap in bulk when on sale, reusing aluminum foil when possible, and investing in reusable alternatives for everyday use. By doing so, you can save money and reduce your environmental footprint. Don’t forget to check sites like RefillWatch to track price changes in your frequently purchased supplies, including trash bags, printer paperAmazon →, and even refillable water bottles. Stay vigilant, and your wallet will thank you!